Pubdate: Mon, 26 July 1999
Source: Irish Times (Ireland)
Copyright: 1999 The Irish Times
Contact:  Letters to Editor, The Irish Times, 11-15 D'Olier St, Dublin 2,
Ireland
Fax: + 353 1 671 9407
Website: http://www.ireland.com/
Author: Arthur Beesley

CALL FOR MORE SPENDING ON PRISON HEALTHCARE

Responsibility for the management of prison health services should be
transferred from the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform to the
Department of Health and Children or to local health boards, the Labour
Party's spokeswoman on health has said.

Launching a discussion document, Healthcare in Irish Prisons, Ms Liz
McManus called for a dedicated budget for prison medical services, which
she said amounts to only 1 per cent of the annual prison budget at the
moment. This contrasted with 6 per cent in England and Wales and 9 per cent
in Scotland.

"Healthcare should be delivered by dedicated healthcare professionals who
should not be in day-to-day prison duties or disciplinary matters," she said.

According to the document, successive reports have highlighted the fact
that prison medical care is inadequate. "Prison-specific problems include
the transmission of infectious diseases due to overcrowding, illicit drug
use and physical violence.

"Most prisoners come from lower socio-economic groups, and are therefore
likely to have more medical problems than the general population. In
addition, mental health problems are common."

The situation in Mountjoy Prison, the State's largest, was particularly
bad, the report said; "70 per cent of the inmates have a history of serious
drug misuse".

Urging the establishment of a primary care centre in Mountjoy men's prison,
the document said this would allow the development of a multi-disciplinary
approach, liaising with probation, welfare and education services. This
would also cater for out-of-hours medical cover and the development of
health promotion services.

Drug services should be "much expanded", said the document, and efforts to
reduce the supply of drugs in prison should be supported.

Ms McManus called for the creation of drug-free wings in all prisons.
Inmates with drug problems should be given access to methadone and to
needle exchange facilities, she said. Addiction counselling services should
be expanded.

Mental health services in prison have failed, said Ms McManus. Padded cells
were used on 500 occasions in Mountjoy in 1997. "At present, existing
psychiatric services in the wider community will not cater for prisoners
and this policy needs review." This was "urgently required". The case for
an expansion of the prison psychological service was "extremely strong".

On the treatment of women prisoners, Ms McManus said appropriate facilities
for mothers and babies should be provided. Women prisoners should have
access to the same range and quality of services, particularly in the area
of drug treatment, she said.

The treatment of sex offenders "needs to be tackled", said Ms McManus.
While 280 men were in prison for sex-related crimes, there were only 10
treatment places each year on a special programme at Arbour Hill. The
Curragh Prison holds almost 100 sex offenders in a treatment-less
environment, she said.

The document is to be discussed by the Labour Parliamentary Party with a
view to becoming party policy. 
- ---
MAP posted-by: Richard Lake