Pubdate: Thu, 16 Dec 1999
Source: Denver Post (CO)
Copyright: 1999 The Denver Post
Contact:  1560 Broadway, Denver, CO 80202
Fax: (303) 820.1502
Website: http://www.denverpost.com/
Forum: http://www.denverpost.com/voice/voice.htm
Author: Bruce Finley, Denver Post International Affairs Writer

DEADLY NO-KNOCK RAID SPARKS FBI PROBE

Mexican National's Death Raises Civil-rights Concerns

The FBI launched an investigation Wednesday into the death of a Mexican
migrant shot repeatedly by Denver police in a no-knock raid.

FBI agents will focus on possible criminal civil-rights violations, said
Christine DiBartolo, U.S. Justice Department spokeswoman in Washington.

Police Chief Tom Sanchez responded: "We're open to scrutiny.

U.S. Attorney Tom Strickland formally requesting an investigation Wednesday
afternoon after conferring with Justice Department officials in Washington.
Such requests require federal officials to follow up with a probe.

Also Wednesday, Mexico's consul general, Carlos Harros, denounced the
killing of 45 year-old Ismael Mena, a father of nine, and the subsequent
response of Denver police. Barros accused them of stonewalling grieving
relatives and Mexican officials.

"There is a proper restitution that should be given to this family -- not
only economic restitution but moral restitution," Barros said.

A fuller story is emerging about Mena, whose home was identified by Denver
police as a suspected crack house in a Sept. 23 warrant secured by Officer
Joe Bini.

The man killed in a hail of gunfire on Sept. 29 was a skilled horseman from
a small ranch who "was living for his family, his eldest son, Heriberto
Mena, 21, a waiter in Los Angeles, said Wednesday in Denver.

He said father worked for most of his life around the western United States
- -- field work, meat-packing, cleaning vehicles -- to support his wife, five
daughters and four sons.

He sent money home to the family's small ranch, located north of San Julian
in the state of Jalisco. He tried to visit every year and stayed as long as
he could afford to. "His dream was to work with horses' and stay in Mexico
- -- yet that wasn't economically possible.

"I believe that what has occurred is an injustice, and I want to have this
cleared up," said Heriberto Mena. Not only did his father deplore drugs, he
knew little about guns, he said.

Sanchez said Wednesday that "there's physical evidence' Mena fired a gun
"more than once' at SWAT officers when they stormed his apartment at 3738
High St. yelling "Policia!' Two officers fired their guns.

Mena died crouched on the bedroom floor where he'd been sleeping.  He
worked the night shift at the Coca-Cola plant. Police found no crack and
made no arrests.

Mexican authorities said Mena was a legal resident. This was his first year
in Colorado. In January, he'd driven to Denver from Idaho because he had
relatives in the Fort Lupton area.

"He stayed with us for six months,' said Carmen Mecillas, Mena's aunt. "He
said he was coming to Denver to get a better job.

At first, he cleaned apartments for $5 an hour. He went to church, didn't
smoke, refused beers when offered, Mecillas said. Then he moved to the
apartment in Denver, a few doors away from an apartment where where police
later found some crack.

Heriberto's last contact with his father was a phone conversation. "He was
asking about the family, he said.

Mena's wife, Maria del Carmen, is unsure how to make ends meet without her
husband. The burden now falls on Heriberto and his brother Jose in Los
Angeles, where they earn $7 an hour, pay $300 a month for cent and figure
they can raise $300 a month for the family.

Denver Mayor Wellington Webb declined to comment on the FBI investigation.

Sanchez said there are legitimate concerns about whether information in the
affidavit was correct. "If somebody dropped the ball on this one, it's
important that we find out,' he said.

District Attorney Bill Bitter passed supervision of a local investigation
to Jefferson County District Attorney Dave Thomas, saying his office could
be accused of a conflict of interest.

"Our office is involved as the prosecutor's office working with the FBI,
reviewing the fruits of their investigation,' said Strickland, the U.S.
attorney.

The FBI probe is separate from any state or local investigation, DiBartolo
said. Mexican government officials requested federal intervention using
diplomatic channels in Washington, Barros said.

Most troubling were the changing stories he received from police, he said.
Also, police refused to share information with Mexican officials, which he
called a violation of international law.

Attorney Roberto Maes is working the case for the family.

He's focusing on the use of no-knock warrants. Denver police obtain more
than 200 a year.

In the wake of Mena's death, Sanchez has required supervisors to approve
all warrants.

Yet "the family intends to assert its claims,' Maes said. In this case of a
Mexican migrant, he said, Denver's police process proved "deliberately
indifferent to the value of human life.'
- ---
MAP posted-by: Richard Lake