Pubdate: Thu, 31 Jul 2014
Source: Philadelphia Inquirer, The (PA)
Page: A19
Copyright: 2014 Philadelphia Newspapers Inc
Contact:  http://www.philly.com/inquirer/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/340
Author: Stephanie McNulty
Note: Stephanie McNulty is assistant professor of government at 
Franklin and Marshall College.

U. S. HELPED CREATE CRISIS ALONG BORDER

For months, the U.S. government has been debating how to best respond
to the wave of migration of unaccompanied minors.

The problem, which is driven by high levels of poverty and violence in
Mexico, Honduras, and Guatemala, has prompted some commentators and
citizens to assert that anyone breaking the law should be sent home,
regardless of age. However, they do so with insufficient awareness
about the direct role that the United States has played in creating
this crisis.

Two major factors - both directly related to the U.S. government, its
businesses, and its people - have fueled the border crisis.

First, the United States played a decisive role in a series of events
that led to military rule, civil war, and genocide in Guatemala.
Although the war has ended, the legacy of violence remains.

Second, Americans' consumption of drugs fuels a drug war that is
taking over Mexico and Central America. The United States needs to
respond to the migration of minors in a way that recognizes our direct
culpability in the violence and instability in these countries.

To better understand this role, we can go back to the 1950s in
Guatemala, when its first democratically elected government came to
power. Juan Jose Arevalo, a leftist (but not a communist), stepped
into the presidency with hopes of democratizing a country that had
been ruled by the military or elites since its independence.

As Stephen Schlesinger and Stephen Kinzer carefully document using
declassified government documents in their book Bitter Fruit: The
Story of the American Coup in Guatemala, the United Fruit Company, a
U.S.-based corporation, implored the U.S. government to get involved
to stop the labor, education, and land reforms that Arevalo and his
successor, Jacobo Arbenz, initiated. The CIA did get involved and cut
short these efforts. "Operation Success" led to the eventual
overthrow of the democratically elected regime, and decades of
military rule and civil war ensued.

All this may seem ancient history to some, but the legacy of these
events is alive and well in Central America. Even after formal peace
accords were signed in 1996, Guatemala remains one of the most violent
countries in the world.

Just as the civil war in Guatemala ( and other countries in Central
America) died down, drug trafficking, fueled by American consumption,
heated up. As the Colombian drug cartels began to fall in the 1980s,
Mexico became the hub of drug trafficking in the Western Hemisphere.
By the end of the 1990s, tons of cocaine, heroin, and marijuana
traveled through our southern neighbor. Where do the drugs end up? In
the United States, where drug use remains high.

Later, when Mexico's government cracked down on drugs, the United
States watched as the "balloon effect" - a term used by some to
describe the effect of cracking down on drugs in one place that makes
it pop up in another - took place. Slowly, Guatemala and Honduras
became home to more gangs and drug traffickers, leading Honduras to
become the most dangerous country in the world.

When I traveled to Guatemala for my research in 2012, I met people who
were afraid to get involved in local politics because they had
experienced so much repression during the war. Guatemalan citizens
stay in their homes after the sun goes down. My family and I witnessed
a shootout on a major highway at 7 in the morning. Guns and gangs are
everywhere in Guatemala; no city or town was immune.

When living in Honduras in 2005, I saw the ravages of the drug trade
on their society. Drug lords built huge houses in my neighborhood
while young kids died in gang fights a few miles away. Shootouts took
place in broad daylight on a regular basis. I saw many people carrying
weapons openly, as arms flowed fluidly around the country. We tried to
stay at home to avoid violence whenever possible. Of course, we were
extremely fortunate - more so than the average Guatemalan or Honduran
- - as we never became victims of the drug violence and gangs that
plague the region.

Educating ourselves about the United States' role in the violence in
Central America and Mexico should remind us how interconnected we are
with our neighbors to the south, politically, economically, and
historically. As the United States struggles to determine how to deal
with this influx of minors, we need to recall how our country and
citizens have helped create the exact situation from which they flee.

Remember, the children are victims of patterns of violence that are
beyond their control. They need to be treated with dignity and
respect, and not as criminals. We owe them that much. 
- ---
MAP posted-by: Jo-D