Pubdate: Thu, 05 May 2011
Source: Vancouver Sun (CN BC)
Copyright: 2011 The Vancouver Sun
Contact: http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/letters.html
Website: http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/477
Author: Neal Hall, Vancouver Sun

B.C. CIVIL LIBERTIES SUPPORTS CLASS ACTION AGAINST RESIDENTIAL GROW-OP
INSPECTIONS IN MISSION

Some Residents Hit With $5,200 Fee Although No Marijuana
Found

The B.C. Civil Liberties Association is supporting a classaction
lawsuit filed Wednesday against the district of Mission over
residential inspections for suspected marijuana grow operations.

Mission's controversial Controlled Substances Property Bylaw has
resulted in home owners being wrongfully charged with violations of
the bylaw, even though no marijuana-growing operation was found in
their residences.

"We have had dozens of complaints," said Micheal Vonn, policy director
of the BCCLA. "The process is fundamentally unfair."

Mission suspended the bylaw last January after complaints from
residents who were hit with hefty fines for small safety violations
but did not have grow operations in their homes.

Resident Len Gratto, for example, was billed $5,200 for an inspection
that found he was growing flowers and cucumbers in the basement of his
Mission home.

Another resident, Stacy Gowanlock, was slapped with a $5,200 fee after
his house was inspected in 2009. No marijuana plants were found. He is
part of the proposed classaction lawsuit filed by Vancouver lawyer
Alexander Markham-Zantvoort.

"The citizens of Mission have tried for years to get the district to
properly review these decisions and fix this program," Gowanlock said.
"It's clear the district is not moving on this, so we have to ask the
courts to remedy the damage."

Some residents hit with $5,200 fines feel they have had their
reputations ruined. At least one has lost their home after the bank
learned of the violation enforcement by Mission, Vonn said.

"It goes on title and the property is devalued," Vonn explained
Tuesday, adding some people have had trouble crossing into the U.S.
because the bylaw violation becomes part of the person's criminal history.

"The fallout has been extremely serious," she said. "I can't tell you
how many people have broken down crying because they have violated the
bylaw but were innocent."

She said the bylaw is unfair because residents don't have any process
of appeal.

"It's the imaginary grow-op bylaw," Vonn said.

She said the Mission bylaw is supposed to enforce safety inspections
of homes and flows from the provincial Safety Standards Act, which
allows hydro companies to disclose high users of electricity to
municipalities.

"We've had long-standing concerns about the safety inspections
themselves," Vonn said. "It's not about safety -it's about looking for
drug operations."

Safety inspections were not supposed to be an "end-run" around the
police need for a search warrant to look for a suspected drug
operations, she said.

"These are very new programs and new areas of law," Vonn said.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Richard R Smith Jr.