Pubdate: Sat, 22 Sep 2007
Source: Houston Chronicle (TX)
Page: Front Page
Copyright: 2007 Houston Chronicle Publishing Company Division, Hearst Newspaper
Contact:  http://www.chron.com/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/198
Authors: Dudley Althaus and Dane Schiller
Note: Althaus reported from Mexico City; Schiller from Houston.
Referenced: The GAO report http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d071018.pdf
Bookmark: http://www.mapinc.org/topics/Mexico (Mexico)
Bookmark: http://www.mapinc.org/people/Felipe+Calderon
Bookmark: http://www.mapinc.org/find?236 (Corruption - Outside U.S.)

MEXICAN OFFICIAL WANTS ARMY OUT OF DRUG WAR

MEXICO CITY - Dealing a blow to President Felipe Calderon's campaign 
against organized crime, the country's top human rights official 
called Friday for pulling the Mexican army out of the drug war.

Jose Luis Soberanes, head of the government's National Human Rights 
Commission, said his investigators had confirmed cases of serious 
abuses by soldiers involved in the campaign, including rapes, 
tortures, robberies and murders.

He said the army isn't trained for the work and called for a gradual 
military withdrawal from what he said should be a civilian police action.

There was no immediate response from Calderon's office.

Soberanes' report outlined abuses in four locations in the last year. 
They include:

. A mass rape of 14 women, one of whom later miscarried, in the 
border state of Coahuila in retaliation for local police's brief 
arrest of a soldier.

. A May 2007 incident in central Michoacan state village in which 
soldiers seeking information about drug traffickers entered houses 
without warrants, tied up residents and raped two women and sexually 
assaulted two minors.

. Another incident following a fatal ambush of an army patrol in the 
same state in May in which soldiers tortured seven civilians and a child.

. A June 1 incident in which soldiers shot and killed three women and 
two children in a pickup that they said had failed to stop at a 
nighttime checkpoint on a rural road in the Pacific Coast state of Sinaloa.

Soberanes said investigators found no evidence of an actual 
checkpoint but that the soldiers were simply camping along the road 
and opened fire on the truck when it passed.

"A policeman is trained to deal daily with citizens," Soberanes said, 
"and in necessary cases uses gradual and measured force. A soldier, 
because of the delicate nature of his task, is physically and 
mentally trained to fight enemies and obey orders."

Soberanes drew sharp criticism last spring for disagreeing with human 
rights officials and leftist politicians in Veracruz state who 
claimed that soldiers had raped and murdered a 73-year-old indigenous 
woman. He said his investigators had found the woman appeared to have 
died of ulcers.

He did not mention that case Friday.

Despite calling for the army's withdrawal, Soberanes said any pullout 
should be slow, because troops make up the only effective public 
security force in many violence-plagued areas.

Faced with underworld violence claiming hundreds of lives a year, 
Calderon ordered a stepped-up army offensive against drug traffickers 
last September. Thousands of troops were sent into Michoacan, Sinaloa 
and other drug producing states as well as to points along the border.

The moves have been met with overwhelmingly popular approval - some 
polls report 85 percent of Mexicans favor them. Officials say the 
offensive has led to a sharp drop in gangland killings in recent months.

Soldiers are thought less susceptible to corruption because they can 
be shifted quickly from one part of the country to another and 
because they usually don't have family where they operate, said Pat 
Ward, deputy director of the White House's Office of National Drug 
Control Policy in Washington.

"If you look at local law enforcement, state law enforcement, federal 
law enforcement and the military, you are more apt to corruption if 
you live there," Ward said. "That is where your family lives and 
where they can pull different levers to either entice you or force 
you down a particular path."

A study released Thursday by the U.S. General Accountability Office, 
Congress' audit arm, found that by 2005 as much as 90 percent of the 
South American cocaine reaching U.S. consumers passed through Mexico.

The amount of cocaine passing through Mexico keeps increasing, from 
242 tons seven years ago to 507 tons last year, the report said.

Mexican drug cartels - mainly four organizations - have grown more 
powerful, sophisticated and violent, the report said, and they 
operate with "relative impunity" along the U.S-Mexico border.

"The sheer volume of this stuff coming across the southwest border is 
just staggering and even more so is the cash being made by these 
criminal organizations," said Steve Robertson, a spokesman for the 
Drug Enforcement Administration.

"There is a battle here," Robertson said. "We are fighting it, and a 
war is only over when one side gives up."
- ---
MAP posted-by: Richard Lake