Pubdate: Wed, 23 Mar 2005
Source: Edmonton Sun (CN AB)
Copyright: 2005, Canoe Limited Partnership.
Contact:  http://www.canoe.com/NewsStand/EdmontonSun/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/135
Author: Mindelle Jacobs
Bookmark: http://www.mapinc.org/rehab.htm (Treatment)
Bookmark: http://www.mapinc.org/youth.htm (Youth)

FORCED DRUG TREATMENT FOR KIDS NOT THE ANSWER

There are no quick fixes to curbing drug addiction, which is why Tory MLA 
Mary-Anne Jablonski's proposal to force drug-abusing kids into treatment 
was bound to fail.

Constitutionally, her private member's bill is a nightmare. As desperate as 
some parents are to get their teens off drugs, mandatory treatment is a 
hit-and-miss approach.

While forced treatment would get kids into care, there's no compelling 
evidence that, in the long term, it works any better than voluntary 
programs, according to experts.

"Anything to expand addiction treatment is a good thing," says Cameron 
Wild, a University of Alberta professor of public health sciences.

"Whether this is a good idea, I have my doubts."

The idea of mandatory drug treatment for kids is fraught with pitfalls, 
says Wild. For one thing, parents might inappropriately use such a law to 
control their children, says Wild.

Parents often can't distinguish between occasional drug use and full-blown 
addiction, and using "heavy-handed" tactics could alienate them from their 
children, he notes.

A relationship of trust between parents and teens is a crucial factor in 
the kind of behaviour kids engage in, he adds.

Nevertheless, Wild says he sympathizes with families in distress because of 
drug problems. "Having a kid with an addiction issue can be really 
devastating to parents and family and friends. People are suffering."

But compulsory treatment orders typically aren't followed up with the 
necessary funding to meet the demand, Wild says. "Often these things sound 
better than they turn out to be."

Kids are already having a difficult time accessing drug treatment in the 
province because of a lack of capacity, he says.

The one bright note is that the Bridges program, an intensive residential 
drug-treatment plan for male young offenders, run by the John Howard 
Society, is likely to be a permanent fixture.

Bridges was a one-year pilot project that was supposed to lose its funding 
at the end of the month but it looks like it will continue, says program 
manager Janice Bardestani.

Teen males who are serving open custody sentences can volunteer to get help 
at the 12-bed centre.

"They really like it. It forces them to be honest with themselves and each 
other," says Bardestani.

But the program is only for teens who have been involved with the justice 
system.

As yet, there are still no residential treatment centres for drug-addicted 
teens who haven't been convicted of a crime.

So even if the province were to pass a law mandating drug treatment for 
teens, where would we put them? We can't even help the young, chronic 
addicts who already need residential treatment.

Last month, Health Minister Iris Evans said that the draft budget contains 
funding for up to four such centres. But political pledges often don't see 
the light of day.

So perhaps it's for the best that we bury the notion of coerced treatment 
before we're forced to acknowledge that there's no structure in place to 
implement it.

Jablonski's heart is certainly in the right place. Parents whose kids are 
addicted to drugs are at their wits' end. Some see forced rehabilitation as 
a solution.

But that approach risks causing even more problems. What about a young 
person's charter rights? Where will we find the beds to house all these 
kids? And will the teens be better off in the end?

"You would rip them out of their social and personal environment against 
their will," says Benedikt Fischer, associate professor of public health 
sciences at the University of Toronto.

The collateral damage may outweigh any benefits of the treatment, he warns. 
"We're fairly helpless on this particular issue," he says of youth drug 
addiction.

Even the experts can't offer much reassurance on this one.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Beth