Pubdate: Sun, 03 Mar 2002
Source: Albuquerque Journal (NM)
Copyright: 2002 Albuquerque Journal
Contact:  http://www.abqjournal.com/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/10
Author: Guillermo Contreras

SEIZURE OF DRUGS RULED ILLEGAL

A judge has ruled federal agents illegally obtained 20 pounds of Ecstasy 
from an Amtrak passenger in Albuquerque in August.

The Department of Justice is pondering whether to appeal the ruling by U.S. 
District Judge C. LeRoy Hansen, who suppressed the $1.25 million in 
evidence seized from Sammy Joseph, 31, who is originally from Sudan but has 
lived in Canada the past two years.

After two days of testimony in early January, Hansen ruled that the 
questioning of Joseph by an agent with a DEA-led task force violated his 
Fourth Amendment rights.

Hansen wrote in his opinion that the drugs were seized as a result of a 
coercive, illegal encounter and detention of Joseph, whose birth name is 
Asim Yousef. Hansen also noted that Joseph - who speaks Arabic - understood 
very little when questioned in English.

"That's really what this case was about, whether or not Mr. Joseph was able 
to comprehend what he was asked and told to do," Joseph's lawyer, David 
Norvell, said.

The U.S. Attorney's Office filed a notice of appeal last week to meet an 
appeal deadline, but is waiting for approval from the Justice Department to 
proceed.

Steven Derr, head of the DEA in Albuquerque, said he could not comment.

The "party" drugs - 50,000 tablets worth about $1.25 million - were seized 
Aug. 20, 2001, after task force agent Jonathan Salazar cut open a box in a 
bag belonging to Joseph. Joseph was traveling from Albany, N.Y., to Los 
Angeles.

Salazar cut the box after questioning Joseph extensively and purportedly 
after Joseph gave consent.

On the witness stand, Joseph testified through an Arabic interpreter that 
he did not really understand when Salazar asked if he could search the bag.

"I did not know or think that I had any other option other than to say 
'yes,' " Joseph said. "He was already with me in the room. And he already 
had the bag on his knees and said, 'Can I search it?' I had no other 
option. I told him, 'Go ahead.' "

In his opinion, Hansen said Joseph was backed into his roomette by Salazar 
and another agent and was asked some 65 run-on questions in nine minutes. 
Hansen also said Joseph was in his underwear and undershirt during much of 
the questioning.

Hansen said Salazar did not tell Joseph that he had a right to refuse to 
answer questions and leave, though the judge acknowledged there is no 
requirement that law officers tell people they don't have to answer 
questions during so-called consensual encounters.

Hansen also noted Salazar asked Joseph for consent to search his belongings 
10 times, "a number that is clearly excessive and coercive."

Although the conversation with Joseph was tape-recorded, the only audible 
answer to Salazar's questions seeking consent to search was after the 10th 
query, Hansen said.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Alex